Shoe problems: fix it, replace it or live with it
A triage table for common shoe problems, from smell and scuffs to worn soles and heel rubbing, with a fix, replace or live with it verdict for each.
Chloé Petit2 min read
Fix the cheap, fast problems. Replace anything that hurts. Ignore anything that only looks tired.
The triage
| Problem | Verdict | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Smell | Fix it | Remove insoles, dry fully, baking soda overnight. See how to get rid of smelly shoes. |
| Heel rubbing | Fix it, then replace if it persists | Try heel lock lacing and short wear. See new shoes rubbing your heel. |
| Scuffed toe | Live with it | A damp cloth removes surface marks. Deep scratches on leather need the maker's care guide. |
| Creased leather | Live with it | Normal. Shoe trees help a little. |
| Flat, hard cushioning | Replace it | Cushioning does not recover. |
| Sole worn through or uneven | Replace it | A cobbler can resole some shoes. Ask before you buy new. |
| Broken insole only | Fix it | Swap in a basic replacement insole. |
| Loose lace or eyelet | Fix it | Rethread, glue or replace the lace. |
Who each verdict is for
Fix it is for problems that sit on the surface or in a cheap part: laces, insoles, smell, dirt. You spend minutes, and the shoe keeps working.
Replace it is for anything structural. If the sole is worn or the shoe causes pain on your feet and joints, it is not saving you money to keep wearing it. Persistent foot pain is covered in sore feet after a day standing.
Live with it is for cosmetic wear. A shoe with a faint crease still protects your foot.
The two questions that decide it
- Does it hurt or change how you walk? If yes, replace it.
- Does the fix cost less than a third of a new pair and take under an hour? If yes, fix it.
If neither is true, live with it.
What not to do
- Do not put leather or glued shoes in a hot dryer. It warps them.
- Do not glue a worn sole and keep wearing it for long walks.
- Do not mix cleaning products on shoes. Use one product at a time and follow the care label.
More to read
Keep reading
New shoes rubbing your heel: stop blisters before they start
New shoes rubbing your heel? A step-by-step fix with a free test, a heel lock lacing trick, simple padding and a clear rule for when to take them back.
Chloé Petit4 min read
Wash trainers by hand or in the machine: which is better
Should you wash trainers by hand or in the washing machine? Hand washing is safer for most pairs. Here is when the machine is fine and how to dry them.
Chloé Petit4 min read
Shrunk jumper: how to stretch it back
A shrunk wool jumper can often be stretched back a size with a soak in lukewarm water and conditioner. Here is how, and when to let it go.
Chloé Petit2 min read
How to fix a stuck zip without breaking it
Fix a stuck zip on a jacket, bag or jeans by freeing the fabric and rubbing the teeth with graphite or wax. Steps, limits and when to replace it.
Chloé Petit3 min read
How to get sweat stains out of white shirts
Get sweat stains out of white shirts with a paste, a soak and a proper rinse. Free fixes first, then what helps with yellow underarm stains.
Chloé Petit6 min read
How to get rid of smelly shoes
How to get rid of smelly shoes with low-cost steps: dry the insoles, wash what you can, use baking soda overnight and rotate pairs so it stays gone.
Chloé Petit2 min read